Louis Wu has posted an item at HBO that Flawless Cowboy (aka Case) made a forum post about the Halo review at Gaming Age.

The review itself is positive, and makes a good counterpoint to PlanetXbox's, which termed Halo disappointing . G-A makes the case that Halo is indeed revolutionary, or at least atypical:

Halo is not your typical first person shooter. In fact, I actually prefer to not even call it a FPS at all. You play from a first person point of view, pick up weapons and kill enemies, but that's where the similarities to your run-of-the-mill FPS ends. Halo is strictly a story driven action/adventure game that incorporates some of the better FPS elements into it. The game most easily comparable would be Half-Life, but even that just pales to the overall scope and vision of Halo.

G-A gave Halo an A (superlative) rating.